Yesterday I submitted a proposal for an imprint I've never written for before, although it's not a different publisher or a different editor. I'm so enjoying the writing that I went beyond the "first three" that traditionally goes with a proposal. Although I hated the required synopsis, that's not a big deal--I hate all synopses, including everyone else's. I wrote what I called (with some embarrassment) a "scrap-paper" proposal for a series that would stem from this book. I just suggested two additional books. In truth, I really only want to commit to one, but I can do two. Any more than that worries me because I'm slow anymore--I'm not sure about...well, you get that.
I don't know how many books I've had published. Writing novellas and the occasional short story for box sets or anthologies confuses the count for me, so I always just say "20-some" and let it go at that. They have almost all been fun, especially in these later years of worrying every time if this will be the last book. I am a hybrid author, but I prefer traditional publishing. For two reasons I can pinpoint--one being that that was where I "cut my teeth" and the other being that I hate promotion and marketing all the way to the bottom of my soul.
The infodump above is so you'll understand what I'm really here to talk about. It's about how different having a project rejected feels when you are many years into a career. It wasn't just any project, but one I poured months of working, a great deal of heart, and a pinch of my soul into. I loved the story. I loved Banjo Creek. I revised the proposal in ways my editor suggested and sent them back. I liked them. He liked them.
The senior editor did not. The rejection didn't invite me to try the same story again, although they did urge me to send them more ideas.
This isn't different, is it? Or it shouldn't be. Most of us have dealt with professional rejection at some point. But even knowing that, this was was different. I hadn't been that devastated in years. And I shouldn't have been. Several months later, I still can't fully understand why I was. Except that it planted a seed--no, something bigger, maybe a bulb--in the back of my mind that maybe I could no longer write books.
I am a professional, so after considerable cursing, wailing, and threats of quitting (maybe I'm exaggerating...), I sat back down to write. I have not stopped.
But it left a mark. I've never been over inundated with self-confidence anyway, and this hit was hard and relentless and the feeling of failure hasn't gone away even though I've released another book and written a couple of novellas and today, finally, sent out a proposal for a series.
At the end of the day, and at the end of this too-long post, I have to own my fear of failure and admit that there are parts of being a published author that haven't changed a lick in the 20-some years I've been one. I don't know whether I want to curse and wail again 😠or if I should suck it up and be grateful to still be in this business that I sometimes hate almost as much as I love.
Thanks for listening!
Girl, rejection is HARD, but you are a FABULOUS WRITER!!!! The best piece of advice I ever got with a rejection was this: "While this project maybe not be suitable for us, I'm sure it is for another line. It only takes one yes amid many no's for success." YES you can write YES you are talented and YES this feeling of inadequacy is something we all, as writers, live with. But be secure in the fact that YES YES YES you can write and write WELL! ~ peg
ReplyDeleteThanks so much, Peggy. Deep down...somewhere, I know this. I think I needed to write it so that maybe it would decrease the shock if this hit anyone else.
DeleteRejection sucks and you know, even without it, I think we're both at age when we're wondering if we have any books left in us--we do, I'm sure of it, but the doubt niggles. We simply must not surrender to it and by submitting a series proposal, you're proving that you are not about to surrender! Yay, you!! ;-)
ReplyDeleteThanks, Nan. As you know, some days surrendering is an idea that has merit. :-)
DeleteRejection is one terrible word. It seems to take forever for the sting to fade, but I know one thing is true. The rejection is the senior editor's opinion. A different senior editor can love your book. That's why we had multiple submission policies developed. Remember, you didn't just magically stop being a writer or stop being a good one because of one person. Take the time you need and then head back to your writing. It's calling you.
ReplyDeleteI never left it. I kept writing, but anyone who know me knows I'm a dweller (I write about that!) and it's still there in the back of my mind that maybe I'm really not good anymore. Gasp! Maybe I never was! I recognize it for what it is, thank goodness. :-)
DeleteSO MANY great comments here already, Liz! I agree with them all. YES, you're a great writer, and YES, you can do it again, and again. Perhaps this was the spark you needed? Perhaps it was the wrong place for the project? I know you love what you do. We all do. Focus on that. Keep going, and don't look back. This year is all about the forward. You got this!
ReplyDeleteI've sent it to other places. We will see. I'm a pretty strong believer in things happening for a reason, but I really don't LIKE it. Lol.
DeleteI'm so sorry! We've all been through it but that doesn't make it any easier. Everyone has opinions and likes different things so this is only one person's opinion. Yay for you to keep going and continue writing! It's what we do!
ReplyDeleteYes, we do, but at least one of us apparently needed to complain about it in a hiccup on the journey. :-) The new proposal is on the editor's desk...well, screen. I hope he loves it.
DeleteNicely put! You would think years of rejection would thicken our skin (and it hasto some extent) but every once in a while that barb hits the vulnerable underbelly and we need to lick our wounds before we dust ourselves off and carry on. How does the saying go? Old writers never die they just scrawl away. Something like that. You got this!
ReplyDeleteLol. I was in wallowing mode, wasn't I?
DeleteRejection is a terrible beast, and it's harder now than it was when I was "green." Your post speaks to me and for me...and probably most other writers!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Amie. You never wish bad on other authors, but I'm glad not to be in the boat alone.
DeleteRejection is awful! It's hard to understand the whys and hows and "we already have a similar one" or "we're moving in this direction" thoughts, but one thing I know. Your characters are always people I adore spending time with. Always!
ReplyDeleteOh, thank you, Beth. I can definitely say the same thing to you!
DeleteLiz, you are a wonderful writer. Your post speaks for all authors everywhere. I've never heard a single person say, "I love rejection." Unless it's some motivational speaker who, I'm convinced, are cyborgs. I often liken submitting and being accepted to a numbers game where every NO is a down payment on a YES. Trouble is, we never know how many NO's we must take before we get a YES. Glad you are still writing.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Joan. I'm afraid I'm one of those whose skin has never thickened enough, like Kathleen mentioned; however, I'm also aware that if it DID thicken to that extent, it wouldn't be good for either my writing or my soul, so here I am whining away! :-)
Delete